Home   /   Mike's Blog

Tuesday, June 27, 2006


NYT's John Tierney: Just Don't Call It Amensty
Today's column by John Tierney in the NY Times contains some interesting information about the immigration debate.

(Tierney's column can be accessed via subscription at www.nytimes.com/pages/opinion/index.html)

Here are the take away paragraphs:

Pay more attention to a recent national poll of likely Republican voters conducted by the Tarrance Group for the Manhattan Institute. These Republicans liked the House's seal-the-border approach to immigration less than the comprehensive approach favored by the Senate and President Bush: combine tough enforcement with a chance for the illegal immigrants already here to pay a fine, become legal and eventaully earn citizenship.

You call this amnesty, and nearly 40 percent of the poll's respondents agreed. Yet 75 percent of all the Republicans favored it anyway.

If you're still terrified of the A-word, consider how Republicans defined it in the poll. It made a big difference how an immigrant went about applying for legal status. If he could apply while staying in America, that was considered a form of amnesty by nearly 60 percent of the respondents. But if he had to go back to his native country and apply, then only 22 percent called it amnesty.

To Mike Pence, that poll result is a "window of opportunity." Pence, the Indiana Republican who leads the House conservative caucus, is dead set against the Senate immigration bill, which he considers amnesty. But he thinks there's a deal to be made before the election by giving immigrants an incentive to go to their home countries in order to get a visa.

Pence wants to beef up border security immediately, and then, once the measures are in place two years later, open up "Ellis Island centers" in Mexico and Central American countries that would quickly match foreign workers with American companies.

If the worker passed background checks and an American employer promised to hire him, he'd get a high tech ID card and a guest-worker visa. During the first three years of the program, there'd be no cap on the number of visas: workers could get visas as long as they had jobs waiting for them.

Archives

March 2004  
April 2004  
May 2004  
June 2004  
July 2004  
August 2004  
September 2004  
October 2004  
November 2004  
December 2004  
January 2005  
February 2005  
March 2005  
April 2005  
May 2005  
June 2005  
July 2005  
August 2005  
September 2005  
October 2005  
November 2005  
December 2005  
January 2006  
February 2006  
March 2006  
April 2006  
May 2006  
June 2006  
July 2006  
August 2006  
September 2006  
October 2006  
November 2006  
December 2006  
January 2007  
February 2007  
March 2007  
April 2007  
May 2007  
June 2007  
July 2007  
August 2007  
September 2007  
October 2007  
November 2007  
December 2007  
January 2008  
February 2008  
March 2008  
April 2008  
May 2008  
June 2008  
July 2008  
August 2008  

Biography | District Profile | News Center | Mike's Calendar | Issue Center | Constituent Services | Photo Album | Kids Page | Contact | Privacy Policy